Allow a single CRB check to apply to several organisations.

At the moment if you are involved with a club or activity involving children you have to apply for a CRB check for each organisation. If you help at (say) Scouts or Guides and are also helping at a kids football, rugby or swimming club you need a separate CRB check for each organisation - even though the information checked is the same and the activities (in the context of contact with children) are similar.

If you had a named list of common organisation types (say - Scouting, Registered Sports Clubs, Schools, Theatres etc) you could have a single CRB check which would be valid for similar activities in all of them. This would save a huge amount of time and money - for the taxpayer, the individual, and the organisations involved.

 

Those organisations or activities that don't fit into these categories could continue with CRB as it is now.

Why the contribution is important

This would eliminate a good proportion of the CRB duplication that happens at the moment. Most people think it's nonsence and wasteful. It costs NFP organisations £12.00 for a CRB check (I think). In my Kids Football Club, with 23 teams and some 50 volunteer officers, managers, and coaches this could potentially cost  £600 or so every three years - even though most of the mums and dads are already CRB checked for other organisations.

This would only need a change in procedure - not law - to effect and could be done with a minimum of effort and cost.

Current rating

4.73333333333
Average score : 4.7
Based on : 15 votes
a440dc
Posted by a440dc July 01, 2010 at 11:03
I have had two crb checks in the past, one to be a presenter on a hospital radio station and one for fostering special needs teenagers. Now I'm being asked for a third to cover a new commercial radio station position. Ridiculous. This is just another tax!
As far as I'm concerned where the individual will not come into contact with children or vulnerable adults then crb checks should not be required at all.

Please login to flag this comment as inappropriate

dbowman
Posted by dbowman July 01, 2010 at 12:28
CRB checks are just a money-raising scheme.

Please login to flag this comment as inappropriate

rutman
Posted by rutman July 01, 2010 at 15:25
a44dc: Absolutely. I would go further, If requested by companies where the business does not involve working with children or vulnerable people it should be withheld.

Please login to flag this comment as inappropriate

rutman
Posted by rutman July 01, 2010 at 15:25
a44dc: Absolutely. I would go further, If requested by companies where the business does not involve working with children or vulnerable people it should be withheld.

Please login to flag this comment as inappropriate

eabblard
Posted by eabblard July 01, 2010 at 16:08
I agree. It costs our small charity £60/head whereas most of our volunteers and staff already have had a CRB check done for other jobs.

Please login to flag this comment as inappropriate

eabblard
Posted by eabblard July 01, 2010 at 16:08
I agree. It costs our small charity £60/head whereas most of our volunteers and staff already have had a CRB check done for other jobs.

Please login to flag this comment as inappropriate

DFJA01
Posted by DFJA01 July 01, 2010 at 17:32
CRB checks were a knee-jerk reaction to a tragic set of events. In the majority of cases they achieve nothing, and will not prevent bad things happening in the future. I believe they should be dropped in all cases except where an individual will be spending significant time alone with children or vulnerable people.

Please login to flag this comment as inappropriate

DFJA01
Posted by DFJA01 July 01, 2010 at 17:32
CRB checks were a knee-jerk reaction to a tragic set of events. In the majority of cases they achieve nothing, and will not prevent bad things happening in the future. I believe they should be dropped in all cases except where an individual will be spending significant time alone with children or vulnerable people.

Please login to flag this comment as inappropriate

DFJA01
Posted by DFJA01 July 01, 2010 at 17:33
CRB checks were a knee-jerk reaction to a tragic set of events. In the majority of cases they achieve nothing, and will not prevent bad things happening in the future. I believe they should be dropped in all cases except where an individual will be spending significant time alone with children or vulnerable people.

Please login to flag this comment as inappropriate

rebeccag
Posted by rebeccag July 01, 2010 at 19:16
Absolutely need to restrict who requires a CRB. The current system is only as it is to cover people when things go wrong.

Making it transferable is a little more tricky - surely it requires a central database, you know the kind of thing that involves handing large amounts of cash to the IT industry for something that still doesn't work properly after a decade.

Please login to flag this comment as inappropriate

moderator_bis
Posted by moderator_bis July 02, 2010 at 08:54
Thanks for taking the time to post your idea.
 
Your idea is similar to others on the website.
 
To keep the discussion going in the one place, please add any further comments to the ideas below, which have a higher number of comments.

- CRB Certificates to be transferable
http://yourfreedom.hmg.gov.uk/[…]/crb-certificates-to-be-transferrable

- CRB checks should be portable
http://yourfreedom.hmg.gov.uk/[…]/crb-checks-should-be-portable

Please login to flag this comment as inappropriate

Please log in to add comments and rate ideas